Today’s Totally Random
Lines
Base slave, thy words are blunt, and so
art thou.
Duke of Suffolk
King Henry the Sixth
Part II Act IV, Scene i, Line 69
Today is Labor
Day, 2026, and since that is a celebration of the worker, I think that I will
take off on the word slave in Today’s Line. After all, who is a harder
worker than a slave?
Nowadays, here
in the United States, in the world of 2026, the word slave has been
under attack. I use the phrase under attack very purposefully. Words are
important, and the proper use of words is important. In the case of the word slave,
this word has been used historically to refer to pretty much any human being
who has been enslaved by another human being. By enslaved, we mean that they
have been subjugated and controlled by another human being and forced to do
whatever this subjugator wanted them too. This has usually meant work, and lots
of it. By historically, I mean to say the word slave has been used to
refer to enslaved people for thousands of years.
Now, sometime
in recent years, someone decided that the word slave was demeaning. Well, it
is. They decided that slaves were people and should be recognized as such, and so
they decreed that it would be good if we referred to them as enslaved people.
In fact, they decided that it was so important that we do this, that we should
not ever use the word slave; we should use the words enslaved person.
So, what do we
gain by this. Well, on the one hand we give the folks in this country who are
the descendants of slaves/enslaved people some consideration, or so they say (I
am reminded of the time several years ago when I asked my daughter-in-law, who was
born and bred in China if she found the word Oriental offensive; she asked me
what I was talking about). On another hand we give many people, like myself,
pause: the pause that comes when we stop to think about something to try to figure
out what it means, and if it makes sense or not. Finally, on another hand we give
some folks on the far-right of the political spectrum more fodder for their
rants against the woke left, and that's the last thing they need.
Make no
mistake, replacing the word slave with the words enslaved person
is well intentioned. I can understand and sympathize with the intent. I think,
though, that when we go so far as to trying to eradicate the word slave,
and by extension the word master, well, I’m not sure we’re doing much
good. If in conversation I say “I’ve always been a slave to my emotions”, do I
need to be apologetic? If I refer to my bedroom as the master bedroom, am I wrong?
I don’t think I
ever said to an apparent descendant of an American slave or ex-slave, “Hey Michelle,
were your descendants slaves?” Why would I ever say that? Conversely, if for
whatever strange reason I were to bring it up to Michelle, I probably would use
the words enslaved people. But by the same token, I am not going to be
eradicating any words from my vocabulary any time soon.
Well, I guess
this has become a rant, and that’s the last thing I wanted it to be. I think I
simply wanted to say that that sometimes when we attempt to show consideration
for people by policing our language, we end up weaponizing that language more. And
that’s not a good thing.
Yeah, I think
that’s all I wanted to say; that, and Happy Labor Day.
Speaking of eradicating words: I'm pretty sure this guy eradicated the word labor from his vocabulary a long time ago (as if it was ever there to begin with).